News: Spotlight Content

Engineers on the news again - by Joe DiPompeo

Joe DiPompeo

Over the past few months I’ve done a number of interviews and on-air segments about two New York City building failures. I’m glad to do them — the public deserves a straight explanation from someone who does this work.

But be clear about what it means when a structural engineer is on television. It means a building has already failed. We show up after. Twice in a few months is not a run anybody in this business wants.

In August I wrote in these pages that I’d made my peace with New York City’s building regulations. I complain about the compliance volume and pay the costs like everyone else, but I argued that this city is different. Density changes the math. A brick off a farmhouse façade in Kansas is a maintenance item. The same brick off a façade above a crowded Manhattan sidewalk is a fatality. The defect is identical. What’s underneath it isn’t.

I wrote that after watching the former Pfizer building on East 42nd St. buckle and hold. Nobody was hurt there.

I did not expect to be writing the follow-up this soon, and I did not expect it to read like this.

On the afternoon of November 11, a three-story building at 1321 Flatbush Ave. in Brooklyn came down into an adjacent excavation site. Part of the building next door was sheared away, leaving apartments open to the street. Eight people were killed and roughly seventeen injured. DOB, FDNY and the Brooklyn District Attorney’s office are investigating. We know a structure failed. At this point that is all any of us knows, and I’m not going to speculate about cause.

Consider the scale. Three stories. In most of this country a three-story building is a small thing; alone on an acre, a total collapse is a property loss and a very bad day. This one was not alone. It came down into the lot beside it and took part of the building on its other side with it. That is the condition I described a few months ago — buildings sitting on top of one another, with nothing between a structural problem and everyone around it. Here, the failure of even a small building is almost never confined to that building. I would rather have been wrong about that.

Our profession’s first obligation — the first canon, before everything else — is to hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the public. Eight people are dead. Whatever the chain of events turns out to be, that standard was not met. To be clear, that is not an accusation against anyone: not the engineers, not the inspectors, not the contractors, not the owners. We don’t know yet who did what, or whether the breakdown was in design, construction, maintenance or oversight. It is an acknowledgment of where the bar sits and the fact that this time we ended up under it.

This is what gets lost in the volume of filings and fees. When a physician makes a mistake, a patient can die. When a structural engineer makes a mistake, a building can come down, and the number is not one. It’s everyone inside, plus whoever is on the sidewalk, plus the neighbors who never signed up for any of it.

Engineers save lives every time the wind blows, every time it snows, every time a crowd fills a floor designed for exactly that crowd. Those successes are invisible by definition, which is why they never make the news.

So we’ll do what we always do. We’ll find out what happened, and we’ll argue about whether the codes and inspection regimes need to change. That cycle isn’t a bureaucratic ritual — it’s the mechanism by which the built environment gets safer, and most of what protects us today exists because of a failure that came before. But the lesson is paid for in advance.

Here’s what concerns me most, and it brings me back to those interviews. In everyone — every segment, every call, every article — I’ve been asked the same two questions. Are we safe? Should people be worried? That isn’t a question about Flatbush or East 42nd St. It’s a question about the building the person asking lives in. After Surfside, and now this, the sudden and complete failure of an occupied building has stopped feeling to the public like a freak event and started feeling like something that happens. That confidence is the quiet product of a century of codes and inspections, and it is not easily rebuilt once it goes.

Buildings should be the thing you don’t have to think about. We cannot keep giving people reasons to.

Joe DiPompeo, PE, F.SEI, F.ASCE is president of Structural Workshop, LLC, Mountain Lakes, N.J.

READ ON THE GO
DIGITAL EDITIONS
Subscribe
Columns and Thought Leadership
CRE Guide Featured Company: Merritt Environmental Consulting Corp.

CRE Guide Featured Company: Merritt Environmental Consulting Corp.

Merritt Environmental Consulting Corp. (MECC) was established in June of 2009 after being part of a larger engineering firm for almost 20 years. The focus of the company is to assist lending institutions, attorneys, real estate investors, and property owners with environmental concerns. Today, MECC has offices in New York, Florida, and Vermont and has grown into a regional consulting firm serving clients along the East Coast.
2026 Developing Long Island: ERG Commercial Real Estate launches its new Retail Leasing division

2026 Developing Long Island: ERG Commercial Real Estate launches its new Retail Leasing division

North Hempstead, NY ERG Retail Leasing is the dedicated leasing division of ERG Commercial Real Estate, an established full-service commercial real estate brokerage for over 35 years. 
2026 Developing Queens: Long Island Board of Realtors  advances commercial growth and advocacy in Queens

2026 Developing Queens: Long Island Board of Realtors advances commercial growth and advocacy in Queens

The Long Island Board of Realtors (LIBOR) Commercial Network continues to play a key role in advancing opportunities and strengthening the commercial real estate landscape across Queens. Through targeted programming and global outreach
From vacancy to vitality: How adaptive reuse is reshaping Long Island’s CRE landscape - by Andrea Tsoukalas Curto

From vacancy to vitality: How adaptive reuse is reshaping Long Island’s CRE landscape - by Andrea Tsoukalas Curto

Adaptive reuse has become one of the most important conversations in commercial real estate today. Long Island has a large inventory of aging retail, office and industrial