New York state has ranked among the nation’s highest property tax states. In an effort to address rising property taxes, New York enacted a property tax cap in 2011. The cap proposed to limit the increase in annual growth of the property tax levy to the lesser of 2% or the rate of inflation.
A common misconception among property owners is that the cap limits increase in an individual property owner’s tax bill. However, this law only caps the tax levy of a taxing jurisdiction (i.e., school districts, towns), as opposed to the amount of real estate taxes an individual property owner is required to pay.
Consequently, an individual’s real property tax bill can increase by more than 2% due to re-assessments, changes on the property, or increases in the tax levies of the taxing jurisdictions that serve the property.
Piercing The Cap.
This cap is aimed at limiting how much the total real property tax revenue can increase. However, it does not prohibit a taxing jurisdiction from increasing its levy beyond 2%. Instead, the tax cap may be overridden when a taxing jurisdiction determines that the revenue is insufficient to maintain its existing and essential services. Notably, certain costs are specifically excluded from the 2% cap, including major school capital expenditures and pension contributions.
For a local government, the governing board must adopt a local law with a 60% supermajority vote. For a school district, voters must approve a budget that exceeds the tax levy by 60% supermajority.
You might be wondering why anyone would vote to raise or pierce the 2% tax cap. The answer comes down to what residents value most: strong school districts; public safety; and an attractive town with well-paved roads and reliable garbage collection.
To illustrate, in September 2026, the Huntington Town Board voted to adopt a local law allowing the Town to pierce the tax cap for its 2027 budget due to increasing costs and rising inflation.
The town board’s decision to pursue an override of the tax cap illustrates the dual nature of the law. While it establishes a statutory framework for limiting runaway tax levies, it also permits municipalities and school districts to exceed the cap where necessary to sustain their existing services.
Camila Morcos is an associate and a member of the tax certiorari practice group at Forchelli Deegan Terrana LLP, Uniondale, N.Y.