With the advent of higher interest rates, it presents a problem for mortgage deals because of debt service coverage ratios. Lenders have different requirements for Debt Service Coverage Ratios (DSCR). DSCR is defined by Net Operating Income (NOI) divided by Annual Debt Service (ADS). Because of these requirements the typical loan/value ratios of 75% or 80% are abandoned in favor of lower loan to value ratios in order to accommodate lender DSCR requirements which generally are no less than 1.2-1.25. It may be lower for multifamily loans or high-quality credit occupied properties. DSCR is higher for office, hospitality, retail with short-term leases, etc. This becomes an issue for appraisals which are completed for lenders. Many of the markets consist of all cash and/or low loan to values transactions especially in high interest times.
Many commercial properties are up to 7.5%+/-. Over the past five years these are high rates. However, the average mortgage interest rates since the early 1970s are just over 7%. So over the long-term, 7.5% isn’t too excessive, but people have short-term memories of rates. Within the last five years, mortgage rates were as low as 3.5%. This created over valuation of assets because of relatively low debt service. For example, a mortgage interest rate of 4% with a DSCR 1.2-1.25 has entirely different implications than for a mortgage rate of 7.5%. For example, a $2.8 million valued commercial property based upon a mortgage interest rate of 4% had a DSCR of 1.2 based upon a 75% loan/value ratio or a 25% down payment. The same value applied to a 7.5% interest rate results in a DSCR of 0.91 which obviously is substantially well below 1.2. However, an all cash or 100% down payment will have no DSCR because NOI can’t be divided by “0.” A lower loan/value with a larger down payment will produce a better DSCR. A lower loan/value ratio of 70% or down payment of 30% results in improved DSCR of 0.97 but still below the threshold of 1.2-1.25. A 65% loan/value or a 35% down payment has a DSCR of 1.05. A 60% loan/value ratio or a 40% down payment has a DSCR of 1.13. A 55% loan/value ratio or 45% down payment will result in a DSCR of 1.24 which is over the minimal threshold of 1.2. Obviously, the down payment requirement increases from $700,000 to $840,000; $980,000; $1.12 million; and $1.26 million respectively. So the amount of down payment increases $140,000; $280,000; $420,000 and $560,000 respectively. This is a very big roadblock in the marketplace which ultimately will reduce market values because of fewer investors who can afford the higher down payments.
While writing this article, I saw the sale of a long-term leased warehouse with a high credit tenant. The property sold earlier this year for $10,032,500. The NOI was $568,990 or an overall capitalization rate of 5.67%. Reportedly, it was part of a 1031 tax free exchange which typically inflates the value of the property for various reasons. For illustrative purposes, assume that there was a 75% loan/value mortgage loan in the transaction at 7% for 20 years. The DSCR is 0.81 well below some guidelines of 1.2-1.25. So it’s likely more down payment higher than 25% or a lower loan/value than 75% would be appropriate. In order to reach a 1.2 DSCR, a down payment of approximately 49% or $4,921,425 is required. This is $2,412,300 more down payment than the more normal 75% loan/value.
In today’s market of higher interest rates lenders are requiring more down payment and less leveraging. It’s obvious why investors don’t want less leveraging. More down payment is required. The hidden reason for leveraging is getting a higher rate of return on the down payment. As an example, I recently appraised a number of properties in which an Internal Rate of Return (IRR) was estimated for two scenarios:
A) 75% loan/value ratio and 25% down payment and
B) 0% loan value ratio and 100% all cash.
For scenario A which was a ground lease assuming a 75% loan/value the IRR was 12.92%.
For scenario B with an all cash transaction the IRR is 9.65%.
Another ground lease assuming a 75% loan/value ratio had an 18.56% IRR for scenario A. For scenario B for a “0” loan/value, all cash transaction had a IRR of 12%. These are examples of leveraged properties having more of a rate of return for each dollar of equity than non-leveraged properties.
In summary, with the higher interest rates there will be more down payments and less leveraging. The result will be lower property values and less rates of return on each dollar invested as equity.
John Rynne, MAI, SRA, is president and owner of Rynne, Murphy & Associates, Inc., Rochester, N.Y.