New York Real Estate Journal

Pied-à-terre tax: A growing problem for New York City property owners - by Peter Blond

November 24, 2026 - Spotlight Content
Peter Blond

In my last article, I mentioned that my worst fears regarding mayor Mamdani’s “tax the rich” non-primary residence surcharge (NPRS) a/k/a pied-à-terre tax had been realized. However, after recently hearing from many respected competitors and non-competitors alike, such as pro se applicants; things are worse than most professionals even imagined possible. It appears, albeit based largely on hearsay, that the City Department of Finance has failed to grant many deserved exemptions for either owner occupied or rented apartments and townhouses. In more sinister fashion, the denials come via flimsy mechanized letters with non-specific omissions or other problems that led to the denial of exempt status for the 2026/27 tax year. I have seen some of these denial notices and they very much support the rumor mill.

Normally, I would assume the pro se applicants had simply failed to dot the I’s or cross those T’s, but too many experienced and savvy attorneys received the same “blank face” causing denials. These savvy attorneys include former heads of New York City agencies! Imagine being paid thousands - as the hired gun - to prevent disastrous outcomes for people facing six figure “surcharges,” and come up slaughtered like the pro se applicants. Any new system with insufficient rules, too many gray areas and brand-new hearing officers tends to produce inconsistent and unfair results under the best of circumstances. In proceedings with such wildly inequitable and unpredictable outcomes, the amounts involved are typically nominal, but these “surcharges” routinely exceed the annual real estate tax bill for the subject townhouse or apartment. Entrusting such decisions to individuals with no track record and a fear of making a mistake in favor of the taxpayer with so much on the line is astonishing.

Historically, the New York City Tax Commission resolved approximately 15% of the annual protests. Lately, that figure has diminished as many former hearing officers and part-time commissioners have left the agency. Most years, a successful real estate tax protest averaged 7-10% off the assessed value. In the case of the NPRS surcharge, most of the time the hearing officers will be deciding between the original surcharge amount or whether it goes to zero (residency would negate the surcharge or perhaps the valuation dropping under the threshold). As one can surmise from the low success rate indicated above, most of the time, NYC Tax Commission hearing officers err on the side of no reduction. When the City’s representatives do take remedial action, it’s “stemming the tide” as opposed to removal of the real estate taxes entirely (barring an exemption for something like a church). If these common philosophical approaches are to be applied by DOF and Tax Commission personnel to the confiscatory NPRS surcharge, many people are going to be selling their pied-à-terre.

Moreover, consider that second half tax bills are due to be released in mid-November, due early January. How many people do you anticipate will proactively pay a six-figure surcharge they believe they should be exempt from entirely before it becomes a lien on their property (or their cooperative)? As is the case on any tax bill item, when it isn’t paid on time, interest and penalties begin to accrue. New York City DOF is charging from 6% to 16% in compounding interest for late payments for 2026/27. Despite many warnings by many people to NYC DOF, a failure by even one cooperative pied-à-terre owner could cause a building-wide disaster even though most unit owners would be innocent. A lien could also interfere with a cooperative’s ability to re-mortgage the property and discourage purchasers.

On a related front, the recent Appellate Division decision regarding the City’s list of potential pied-à-terre villains neglected to consider that many of these people may decide to sell. By listing pied-à-terre “shamed” apartments or townhouse, the city has effectively impacted the resale value of that unit by announcing that the owner is looking to get out from under this burden. It would be the equivalent of New York Courts releasing a list annually of divorce filers, business break-ups, etc. This is not a normal list, and it was done for reasons that have absolutely nothing to do with business as usual considering the list was over-inclusive and doesn’t serve as legal notice. 

There are lawsuits still pending with much more “bite” than the Staten Island filing that solely focused on albeit irritating and unnecessary politicization of Mamdani’s “tax the rich” flotilla. It would be impossible for anyone to argue that the NPRS surcharge isn’t retroactive and/or confiscatory. These actual Constitutional concerns will pose a serious problem for the city and Albany for phase one (phase two isn’t retroactive although it will still be confiscatory at these levels). As a recent Democratic winner in California felt no shame in saying, “Lawyer up!”

Peter Blond, Esq. is a partner at Brandt, Steinberg, Lewis & Blond LLP, New York, N.Y.