New York Real Estate Journal

New York clarifies option for property owners with excess carbon emissions - by Tristan Schwartzman

November 24, 2026 - Spotlight Content
Tristan Schwartzman

In New York City, where buildings are the largest source of greenhouse gas emissions, Local Law 97 is designed to reduce those emissions from buildings over 25,000 s/f in size. It sets aggressive emissions reduction targets well into the future and imposes significant penalties for not meeting those targets. It’s an important local initiative that may well become a model for other cities, and its implications are, therefore, important in New York City and beyond.

While the initial deadline for compliance was May 1, 2025, one element of the law became newly clarified in August 2026. That provides valuable information on one option for property owners.

One of the law’s stipulations allows for two alternatives to paying a penalty for excess emissions, and New York State’s energy agency NYSERDA announced in August the pricing of that option. That pricing makes it attractive for certain properties, as I know from our work at Goldman Copeland, where we have helped bring about 200 commercial and institutional properties into compliance with Local Law 97.

Of the two alternatives, one has little financial benefit but may be appealing in another way. It allows building owners facing Local Law 97 emissions limits to buy carbon offsets that directly finance energy efficiency upgrades in local low-income housing through the city’s Affordable Housing Reinvestment Fund. Property owners can thereby ensure that their funds address energy efficiency. The cost of those offsets, however, is virtually the same as the cost of the penalty, so it’s a conceptual preference rather than a financial one.

The other alternative is more intriguing financially. It’s known as RECs, which stands for Renewable Energy Certificates and funds the new electric energy line coming from Canada to bring energy to New York City. 

Property owners can purchase RECs instead of paying the penalty, but there is a minimum purchase of 1,000 RECs, so the option may not be attractive if a property is barely over the line. Still, this is the first time that there is an option that costs less than the penalty, and with the recently unveiled pricing by NYSERDA, it’s now possible to calculate the option more precisely. 

A range for the anticipated pricing had previously been announced: between $20 and $50 per REC. The actual price of $35.52 falls in the middle of that range and enables calculations that had previously been only speculative. While that price applied only to a limited quantity of 50,000 RECs and to a brief time period – two weeks ending on September 2 that constituted the Voluntary Summer Sale for Vintage 2027 Tier 4 RECs – it nevertheless set a standard that is valuable for future calculations. For reference, the equivalent penalty for each excess megawatt-hour of emissions is $77.44 during the first phase of Local Law 97, from 2024 to 2029.

The next offering of RECs will be next spring at a price that is widely expected to be comparable to the initial price, although likely to increase gradually – in part to provide incentive for buying RECs early. It’s also possible to buy long-term contracts for RECs, so locking in an early price can be beneficial.

While the precise next price is not known, nor is the size of the next RECs offering, much greater pricing clarity now exists. That makes it possible to assess this option more fully.

Our overall advice to property owners in this regard is, therefore, as follows:

First, meet your Local Law 97 emissions limits wherever possible and financially feasible. That’s typically the most cost-effective and certainly the most energy-efficient approach. Retro-commissioning, existing system optimization, lighting retrofits, and HVAC control upgrades are typically cost-effective methods to reduce greenhouse gas emissions as well as utility costs, and should be the first line of defense against Local Law 97 penalties.  

Second, if for some reason a property is over the limit and needs to pay a penalty, RECs are your best option. While the minimum of 1,000 RECs applies, owners of property portfolios can apply the minimum to any buildings in the portfolio. RECs can also be split among a group of owners.

Third, by visiting NYSERDA’s webpage on the topic, one can explore how to buy RECs through the New York Generation Attribute Tracking System (NYGATS). Based on the NYSERDA price of $35.52, we at Goldman Copeland conducted a break-even analysis to determine the point at which RECs would be worthwhile, based on the first phase of Local Law 97 from 2024 to 2029 and a minimum order of 1,000 RECs. At the recent price of $35.52 per REC, a building’s excess emissions would need to be greater than 133 tons of CO2 equivalents in order to benefit financially from the RECs. 

Fourth, the option of a long-term contract for RECs is worth considering. The minimum is 10 years, and an owner can negotiate with NYSERDA to lock in a fixed contract price over the term. This option, however, loses benefit over time, because RECs only apply towards grid-purchased electricity, and emissions from grid electricity must be reduced, according to Local Law 97, by 50% starting in 2030.

Reducing energy emissions is a vital environmental concern. Understanding how Local Law 97 addresses that concern is crucial to making the best decision for every affected property. NYSERDA’s new pricing clarity makes it possible now to cost out the options with new precision.

Tristan Schwartzman is co-managing principal and director of energy services at Goldman Copeland, Manhattan, N.Y.