New York Real Estate Journal

Recent changes in title insurance - by Thomas Kearns and Hyman Kindler

November 24, 2026 - Owners Developers & Managers
Thomas Kearns

 

Hyman Kindler

 

In 2024, the New York Title Insurance Rate Service Association (TIRSA) Rate Manual was significantly overhauled. This article addresses a common misconception with respect to one type of coverage: the TIRSA Identified Exception & Identified Risk Coverage Endorsement.

Prior to 2024, title insurance companies were able to address risks raised by specific exceptions in a title insurance policy by inserting language after such exceptions, insuring the policy holder against said exception, or narrowing the risk such exception would pose. That additional language was commonly known as “affirmative insurance,” and was provided at no cost to the insured.

As part of the 2024 changes, title insurance companies are prohibited from issuing affirmative insurance, but can provide somewhat similar coverage through various endorsements to the policy, albeit for a fee. Such endorsements insure, for example, against consequences arising from party walls, rights of first refusal, options, encroachments, and covenants, conditions and restrictions (both on developed land and land under development).

If there is a title exception not otherwise addressed in the other promulgated endorsements, title insurance companies can issue the TIRSA Identified Exception & Identified Risk Coverage Endorsement (Identified Risk Endorsement) in lieu of the old affirmative insurance, at a cost of (a) $150 per Identified Risk for residential real property, and (ii) $250 per Identified Risk for commercial real property. The endorsement requires that the title defect, restriction, encumbrance, or other matter raised as an exception in the title insurance policy be specifically listed in the endorsement. 

Generally, the Identified Risk Endorsement insures against loss or damage sustained by the insured by reason of the specific identified risk, but, unlike affirmative insurance, the endorsement does not cover defense costs. The endorsement specifically states that loss or damage is insured by reason of “a final order or decree enforcing the Identified Risk in favor of an adverse party.” The endorsement goes on to say that issuance of the endorsement “does not obligate the company to establish the title free of the Identified Risk or to remove it.”

Such exclusion of defense costs also affects the way in which counsel for buyers and sellers negotiate “permitted exceptions” in contracts of sale. Prior to the ban on affirmative insurance, one common qualifier to certain permitted exceptions was “so long as the title company insures over said exception.” Depending on the facts, circumstances and negotiating leverage of the parties, such qualifier may need to be altered to “so long as the title company endorses over said exception” - with the understanding that with the Identified Risk Endorsement, the buyer is left exposed to the risk of defense costs – or perhaps the seller will agree that the buyer need not close with the subject exception in place.

The exclusion of often prohibitive defense costs demonstrates the stark difference between the former available affirmative insurance and the Identified Risk Endorsement. Industry professionals are cautioned to fully assess such defense costs before relying on the Identified Risk Endorsement as a means of neutralizing a title insurance risk.

Hyman Kindler is a partner and Thomas Kearns is Of Counsel with Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP, Manhattan, N.Y.